USS Clueless - No war this year
     
     
 

Stardate 20021206.1621

(On Screen): I've been blindsided. I'm concerned. I'm worried. I'm apalled. I'm actually a bit pissed off. I did not expect that when Iraq filed its omnibus "We don't have any weapons" report this weekend that the report would first have to go through weeks of processing and evaluation by UNMOVIC and the IAEA before copies of it were given to members of the Security Council.

That's not mandated by the language of UNSC Resolution 1441, but apparently the members of the council agreed today to let the report be checked, evaluated and censored before copies of it are given to UNSC members. The concern, apparently, is the ten non-veto powers, because the information in the report could conceivably help them learn to make WMDs. It's hard to see how there could be any danger in giving the raw report to the veto powers, since all five of them already know how to make all the kinds of weapons that Iraq has had in the past and is thought to have been trying to make recently, but I guess the idea of treating the ten transient members differently wasn't acceptable.

The first concern I had wasn't actually justified. I worried that given UNMOVIC's apparent commitment to the primary goal of making sure to not give the US any excuse to attack (as opposed to trying to actually find what Iraq is concealing) that it might go beyond merely removing information which could help spread knowledge about making WMDs and also redact anything that could be used as an excuse by the US to attack. But the reality is that our excuse will not be what is in the report, but rather what isn't, and as such UNMOVIC can't actually do anything about that.

More of a worry is the time this is going to take. They're talking about weeks of work, especially if the majority of the material is in Arabic. It's expected to top 10,000 pages, and it would have to be translated, and then painstakingly checked against records UNMOVIC and the IAEA already have, and we could be talking weeks or even months.

All of which means that my prediction of war before the end of the year just went into the trashcan. It's not going to happen, unless Bush decides to claim that UNMOVIC itself is stalling, and moves anyway. (For example, by using something else entirely as a provocation, or outright deciding to move without any provocation.)

Donald Sensing has been saying that conditions in Iraq are not optimal for war now anyway. He has always thought that February was more realistic both in logistical terms and also in terms of ground conditions. I hope he's right.

Update: Andrew Solovay comments. It's definitely true that this report remains one of the critical steps, but I'm not sure I believe that we can use it as justification for a "material breach" if we haven't seen it. As long as it's rotting in UNMOVIC's HQ, the only good thing about it is that it will be out of Iraq's hands and a political timebomb waiting to go off. But it means UNMOVIC controls the timer, not us.

Update: Maybe it's not quite so bad. The inspectors actually found some mustard gas, and actually have said so. (Will wonders never cease?)

Update 20021209: Reversing the earlier decision, the five permanent menbers of the SC were each given copies of the Iraqi report today.


include   +force_include   -force_exclude

 
 
 

Main:
normal
long
no graphics

Contact
Log archives
Best log entries
Other articles

Site Search

The Essential Library
Manifesto
Frequent Questions
Font: PC   Mac
Steven Den Beste's Biography
CDMA FAQ
Wishlist

My custom Proxomitron settings
as of 20040318



 
 
 

Friends:
Disenchanted

Grim amusements
Armed and Dangerous
Joe User
One Hand Clapping


Rising stars:
Ace of Spades HQ
Baldilocks
Bastard Sword
Drumwaster's Rants
Iraq the Model
iRi
Miniluv
Mister Pterodactyl
The Politburo Diktat
The Right Coast
Teleologic Blog
The Review
Truck and Barter
Western Standard
Who Knew?

Alumni

 
 
    
Captured by MemoWeb from http://denbeste.nu/cd_log_entries/2002/12/Nowarthisyear.shtml on 9/16/2004